Vowels
For speakers of English the consonants of Esperanto don't
present much of a problem (with the exception of /r/ and /l/), because they are very
similar to those of English. The vowels
are more difficult. (Just the opposite
is true for speakers of Spanish.) Even so,
the vowels of Esperanto are similar to those of English, and to pronounce them
correctly it is sufficient to focus on diphthongization and vowel
reduction. Don't diphthongize
Esperanto vowels and don't reduce them to schwa.
However, you may find a more complete description of the
Esperanto vowels helpful and/or interesting.
Such a description follows.
The five vowels of Esperanto and their English counterparts
Vowels are produced when the lungs push air through the
mouth. The mouth functions as a
resonance chamber, and by varying the shape of this chamber, primarily by means
of the tongue, we produce different vowel sounds. Consonants are characterized by a complete or
partial blockage of the oral cavity, whereas in the case of vowels there is no
blockage and we can prolong the vowel sound as long as we can continue to expel
air from the lungs. The vocal chords
vibrate during vowel production.
Many languages have a basic vowel system consisting of five
vowels, and Esperanto is one of them.
These five vowels can be represented in a 2-dimensional diagram based on
the position of the tongue.
front central back
high i u beet boot
see Sue
mid e o bait boat
say so
low a bot father
The letters which represent these vowels in Esperanto appear
in the diagram to the left. These
letters are used in the same way in the International Phonetic Alphabet and in
many languages, e.g., Spanish. English
is probably unique among the languages of the earth in the way in which it uses
these letters to represent vowel sounds.
This is a consequence of a major change in English pronunciation which
occurred about 600 years ago and is called the Great English Vowel Shift. The English words to the right indicate the
sounds approximately. Pronounce these
sounds and try to feel what your tongue is doing. It is also helpful to look in a mirror. Note also the role of the lips.
There is an important difference between the non-low Esperanto
vowels and their English counterparts.
All five vowels in Esperanto are pure in the sense that there is no
tongue movement during their production.
That means that they can be prolonged as long as we continue to expel
air from the lungs. The non-low English
vowels are diphthongs consisting of a pure vowel following by tongue
movement. This tongue movement is called
a semi-vowel or an off-glide. The term
'off-glide' is suggestive because the tongue either moves or glides upward and
forward to the position of the high front vowel /i/
(a front off-glide indicated in Esperanto by the letter 'j') or upward and back
to the position of the high back vowel /u/ (a back off-glide indicated in
Esperanto by the letter 'ŭ'). You
should be able to feel and/or see the movement of your tongue and your
lips. The English vowels could be
indicated by the following diagram:
front central back
high ij uŭ beet boot
see Sue
mid ej oŭ bait boat
say so
low a bot father
Unlike English the five basic vowels in Esperanto are not
diphthongs, and it is very important for English speakers to strive to avoid
tongue movement and to produce pure vowels.
The vowels in Spanish are a good model.
Diphthongs
In addition to these 5 pure vowels, Esperanto has 7
diphthongs, only 3 of which are common.
They are
front central back
high uj buoy gooey
mid ej oj bay boy say
soy
low aj buy sigh
front central back
high
mid eŭ oŭ boat low
low aŭ bout cow
With the exception of /eŭ/,
which does not occur in English, these diphthongs are pronounced as in
English. /eŭ/
occurs in Spanish in the word 'Europa' = Europe. It is easy to produce. Just start with the pure vowel /e/ and move
the tongue upward and back to the position of /u/.
/aŭ/ as in English 'bout', /aj/ as in English /buy/, and /oj/
as in English 'boy' occur frequently in Esperanto and in other languages. /eŭ/ and /uj/ are somewhat less frequent. All five have something in common which is
lacking in the 4 English diphthongs which are to be avoided. The off-glides are intrinsically high, and /aj/ and /aŭ/ combine a low vowel and a high off-glide. /oj/ and /uj/ combine a back vowel and a front off-glide, and /eŭ/ combines a
front vowel and a back off-glide. In each case there is contrast between the
position of the vowel and the off-glide.
To be avoided are the cases where there is no contrast: a front
non-low vowel combined with a front
off-glide, and a back non-low vowel
combined with a back off-glide.
Lax vowels
The 4 non-low English vowels mentioned above with the
off-glide removed are common in the languages of the world and are called long
vowels or tense vowels. In English there
is a corresponding set of short or lax vowels.
The /a/ in 'father' is also a lax vowel.
In the production of tense vowels, the muscles of the mouth are
relatively tense; in the production of the corresponding lax vowel, they are
relaxed and the tongue tends to move slightly toward the center of the
mouth. Try pronouncing some of the
tense/lax pairs and see if you can feel these changes. For the lax vowels in the following chart I
use the standard IPA (International
Phonetic Alphabet) symbols.
front central back
high ɪ ʊ bit put sit soot
mid ɛ ɔ bet bought set
saw
low a bot father
The lax vowels of 'bit', 'put', and 'bought' do not occur in
Esperanto, and we needn't concern ourselves with them further. However, both the tense vowel /e/ and the lax
vowel /ɛ/
of 'bet' occur in the speech of many
speakers of Esperanto, and the distribution probably depends on the
distribution in the native language of the speaker. Use whichever one makes you feel comfortable. Both also occur in Spanish, where the
distribution is as follows: before /r/
or /rr/ and in closed syllables (those which end in a
consonant) use [ɛ]; otherwise use the tense vowel
[e]. In fact among native speakers there is substantial variation in this distribution.
Vowel reduction
One
other important matter needs to be mentioned.
Another vowel is common in English.
It is the mid central low-energy vowel called schwa designated by the
symbol /ə/. I call it a low-energy
vowel because the tongue is in a neutral middle-of-the-mouth position, and it
doesn't take much effort to produce it.
Loosely speaking, lax vowels become schwa when they are not
stressed. This process is called vowel
reduction. An example is the pair
galaxy/galactic. In the first member of
the pair, the second vowel is unstressed and is reduced to schwa. In the second member, the first vowel is
unstressed and is reduced to schwa.
Vowel reduction does not occur in Esperanto, and English speakers should
strive assiduously to avoid it. Every
vowel has the same sound, whether stressed or unstressed.
On-glides
The glides mentioned above, which indicate tongue movement, are often called
semi-vowels. They always occur next to a
pure vowel. When they follow the vowel,
they are called off-glides and convert the pure vowel into a diphthong.
They can also occur before a vowel, in which case they are called
on-glides. They still indicate tongue
movement, but now in the opposite direction.
The front on-glide represented by the letter 'j' is movement of the
tongue from the position of the high front vowel /i/
to the position of the following vowel, and the back on-glide represented by
the letter 'ŭ' is movement from the position of the high back vowel 'u' to
the position of the following vowel.
Linguists
create models to describe languages.
These models are not absolute, and different models may be useful for
different purposes. In the above
description I have suggested that Esperanto has 12 vowels, 5 of which happen to
be pure vowels and 7 of which happen to be diphthongs. It would also be possible to say that
Esperanto has only 5 vowels along with 2 semi-vowels and that there are 7
combinations of vowel + semi-vowel, which we call diphthongs. In this latter view not all possible combinations
of vowel + semi-vowel occur. It may be
convenient to consider the on-glides as part of the system of consonants.
Consider
the two words 'mielo' = honey and 'mjelo' = medulla spinalis, part
of the nervous system contained in the spine.
In order to pronounce the two vowels in 'mielo'
which occur in succession, the tongue has to move from the position of /i/ to the position of /e/.
That movement is precisely how I have described the on-glide /j/, and
correspondingly the difference in pronunciation between the above two words is
very slight.
From
an esthetic point of view there is an unfortunate asymmetry in the vowel system
of Esperanto. The back on-glide /ŭ/
naturally occurs in many languages, for example, in the English word 'water',
but there is a rule in Esperanto, introduced by Zamenhof,
probably under the influence of German where it does not occur, which says that
the letter 'ŭ' occurs only after
vowels. In modern terminology, the back
off-glide occurs, but the back on-glide does not (except for a very small
number of specialized purposes). Where the back on-glide occurs in other languages, Esperanto
substitutes /v/. Thus 'Gvatemalo' = Guatemala and 'Nikaragvo'
= Nicaragua. 'kvar'
= four and 'kvin' = five are from Latin 'quattuor' and 'quinque'
respectively. Compare the pronunciation
of English 'quarter', 'quintet', Spanish 'cuatro'.
Updated 2/15/2005